It was meant to be rhetorical. I certainly don't mind the feedback, but I also don't think I've asked this question before either. I copy-pasted this post from the last time I did member cuts (link (http://sortedchallenge.livejournal.com/314614.html)) and simply replaced the number of non-member watchers and the link to the current challenge. I wasn't planning or explicitly trying to ask for feedback. As you can see, last year when I posted this question, I did not get responses as the members took it rhetorically. As I said, I don't mind feedback, but typically posts specifically asking for feedback will be locked to members only (this post is public) and have screened comments so that members can speak freely without fear of other members being critical of their feedback. You can feel free to give either of us feedback any time without being specifically prompted. Once again, I would like to link you to the questions and suggestions post (http://sortedchallenge.livejournal.com/412627.html). It has screened comments, making it a better option than this post for sharing candid thoughts on challenges and on the moderation of this community.