I like both methods, myself. Wait, I just typed out a comment and then deleted it, because I don't know the answer......how is it tallied when the voting is done the other way? Does a vote for 1st place get 5 pts 2nd 4 points, 3rd 3 points (the point numbers are just examples) and then each icon/banner gets their total added up and the highest 4 are the winners? Or is it just a separate vote for each one? I hope it's the former, the latter seems like the results might be somewhat inaccurate.
I like that we can see which banner is winning, since it's anonymous, and only the winners get named, it's not embarassing if you don't get a lot of votes, but you also know if you *did* get any votes. I didn't make a banner this time, the new deadline made me forget, but way back in the first two contests for Sorted Challenge that I participated in I made icons and I could see how well (or bad, as the case was) that I was doing. I have a morbid curiousity to see if I got any votes on my other crappy non winning entries, so yeah, this was nonsensical and long winded. Whoops. ;o) Erm, can't wait for the next challenge? Isn't voting for this over, anyway?
no subject
I like that we can see which banner is winning, since it's anonymous, and only the winners get named, it's not embarassing if you don't get a lot of votes, but you also know if you *did* get any votes. I didn't make a banner this time, the new deadline made me forget, but way back in the first two contests for Sorted Challenge that I participated in I made icons and I could see how well (or bad, as the case was) that I was doing. I have a morbid curiousity to see if I got any votes on my other crappy non winning entries, so yeah, this was nonsensical and long winded. Whoops. ;o) Erm, can't wait for the next challenge? Isn't voting for this over, anyway?